Help me choose the packaging design for my freckle pen 🤠 (photo inside the post)

Here are the options!!

Seeds look so cute😍

I like 2 the best because I knew immediately what I was looking at. One more thing to consider (although feel free to disagree with me), if it’s not to late I think it could add some more visual interest to make the packaging a brown color (for dirt). Just my opinion but I think it could be cool.

I voted for 2 because I think it has more interest, maybe making the vine and leaves a brighter green?

Agree with the other callouts to rework #1 with more concentrated seeds, but my biggest feedback was around colors. So many pen products on market are either black or white - which likely is a costing choice - but it wouldnt it be so lovely as a deep raspBERRY or wine color with pale pink accents to help it pop in a makeup bag? 😍

I voted for two because it’s prettier, but do you think there could be a combo, with the vines on top, and the seeds on the bottom, laid out like they would be on a strawberry 🍓 so basically the cap is the “top” of the strawberry and the pen is the “fruit” of the strawberry? Like the actual fruit?

love one!!! strawberry seeds🍓🍓🍓

I’m loving the strawberry seeds! So cute! But maybe more of them but somehow incorporate actual strawberries as well 🥹

Team Seeds!!🍓

battle of the 🍓👀🫐